Review of Grounding Human Rights in a Pluralist World by Grace Y. Kao, and Christianity and Human Rights: An Introduction ed. by John Witte, Frank S. Alexander

Grace Kao's Grounding Human Rights in a Pluralistic World and Christianity and Human Rights, edited by John Witte and Frank Alexander, both contribute to the growing and sophisticated literature addressing the relationship between religious traditions and human rights. Kao's book opens by asking whether "the very idea of human rights [must] be premised upon a religious or meta physical idea in order to be conceptually intelligible, sufficiently protected, or practically stable over time" (4). Kao proposes that this question has generally been answered in one of two ways: a "maximalist" response that identifies religion as a necessary foundation for human rights, and a "minimalist" response that rejects this turn to religion. A significant portion of the book is devoted to assessing representatives of these two approaches. Chapter 2 includes a discussion of maximalist thinkers Michael Perry, Max Stackhouse, Hans Küng, and Nicholas Wolterstorff. Chapters 3 through 5 consider different forms of minimalism, including that found in the work of John Rawls and Martha Nussbaum